Cape Cod has a long history of sea-faring men, and many of its original homes were built to house sea captains. The men are long dead, but their homes are still occupied, and ghosts of the past make themselves known to these current occupants. Katy reads from Ghosts, Myths and Legends as told to the Historical Society of Old Yarmouth, a collection of ghost stories from the new residents of these saltbox homes.


First off, we announce our giveaway winner!! Congrats!! And then we get to the spooky business of telling the story of a family whose paranormal pests are becoming too much to handle. For a much needed dose of compassion and levity in the paranormal tv world, Katy turns to the Rescue Mediums to sort it out.

Become a patron @

Email your spooky story at

Morgan takes us to her new favorite place because she missed the Yule Lads so, we’re back in Iceland! She tells three little stories of spooky happenings in this strange country.

Enter our Giveaway!! Email a screenshot of your Apple Podcasts review to (where you can also send ghost stories) and you can get The Campout Cookbook!

Become a patron at

Katy tells the disturbing tale of the Phelps Mansion on Elm St. in Stratford, CT. Not your typical haunting, this is one of those stories where the claims are so incredible it’s hard to believe people in the 1850s had to deal with it. However, it was corroborated by many journalists and visitors, so listen to the Phelps’s tale and decide for yourself.

Enter the giveaway by emailing a screenshot of your apple podcasts review to where you can also send your ghost story.

Become a patron at

2020 is upon us! But the future is spooky so Morgan took us to the past. Well, kind of. Morgan is the story teller this week and she’s chosen Amish Haunting to bring us into the new decade, which is appropriate because Morgan and Katy are very much old village women from 1743 so we feel comfortable with modern people who slaughter their own pigs. Listen, laugh, and be uncomfortable but never forget, there ain’t no happy endings in Amish country.

Become a patron at

Email your scary story at

Morgan and Katy are taking a break for the holidays but enjoy this wonderful and terrifying ghost story from My Ghost Story.

A pregnant young woman hastily moves into a home that seems way too nice for the price, and when she finds a baby’s shoe in the room that would be her nursery, she takes it as a good sign! But should she?

Become a patron @

Email your ghost story @